Holiday shopping: Should You Buy Last Year’s Laptop on Black Friday?

The M5 MacBook Air is the place to start if you’re buying an Air today. The M4 is still a capable computer, but the older model needs a clear discount from a seller you’re comfortable buying from. A listing that sends you into “Other sellers” without an obvious offer deserves another look before you treat it as a bargain.

The base configurations also differ. The 13-inch M4 started with 16GB of memory and a 256GB solid-state drive (SSD); the current 13-inch M5 starts with 16GB and 512GB. Compare those details before deciding what the newer chip is worth. [1][2]

If you already own an M4 that does what you need, keep it. This comparison is for someone buying a laptop, not a reason to replace a working one.

Start with the M5, then price the M4

Use a 13-inch M5 with 16GB of memory and 512GB of storage as the reference purchase. It’s a configuration worth considering for documents, browsing, video meetings and ordinary photo work. Someone with large creative projects or heavier multitasking should decide on memory first, then compare generations at that capacity.

The newer model adds the M5 chip and updated wireless hardware, including Wi-Fi 7. Those changes won’t make every task feel different. The extra starting storage may be more useful to you than a faster processor, especially if your current computer is already running short of space. [2]

A clearance M4 with the right configuration can still win on cost. But compare it against the current selling price of the M5, not its launch price or a crossed-out figure on a retailer’s page. If the newer Air is on sale too, the saving on the older one may be much smaller than the advertisement implies.

The M4 still handles ordinary work well

There’s nothing about the M5’s arrival that makes an M4 slow at opening documents, managing a household spreadsheet or joining a call. RTINGS’ testing of the M4 Air found strong general-productivity performance and good build and input-device quality. Those are useful qualities in a laptop you carry and type on every day. [3]

The M4’s fanless design also keeps it quiet. The tradeoff is sustained processing: RTINGS found that it reduces performance under prolonged heavy load. If you export long videos repeatedly under deadlines, compare an actively cooled laptop or a desktop. For an occasional editing project, the time saved may not justify the extra purchase cost. [3]

A discounted M4 is therefore worth considering for a student, home computer or portable work machine. The question is whether the actual offer saves enough after you allow for storage, condition and warranty.

Match storage before comparing prices

A base M4 and a base M5 aren’t equivalent configurations. Both start with 16GB of memory, but the M5’s 512GB drive is twice the stated capacity of the M4’s 256GB drive. Apple offered larger drives in the M4 as well, so look at the individual listing rather than assuming every older Air has the smallest one. [1][2]

Configuration What to compare
M4, 16GB / 256GB A lower-cost option if your files fit, with a meaningful storage compromise against the base M5.
M4, 16GB / 512GB A closer comparison with the base M5. Match condition and warranty before judging the discount.
M5, 16GB / 512GB The starting point for a new Air purchase.
M5, 16GB / 1TB A larger-storage configuration, not the base model.

Check used storage on your current computer and leave room for growth and temporary working files. External drives can be sensible for a photo archive or backups, but moving everything onto one just to make a small internal drive work is an inconvenience you should choose deliberately.

Amazon’s “There is a newer version of this item” panel may point to a 1TB M5. That doesn’t mean 1TB is the entry configuration or the only newer Air available. Go back to the capacity selector and compare 512GB options if that is what you need. The suggested product can also differ in color or included coverage. [2]

How much cheaper should the M4 be?

For a new M4 and M5 with matching memory, storage and comparable warranty, we’d look for roughly $200 in savings before choosing the older machine. That is our buying rule, not a current sale price. A $50 difference would send us to the M5. If a sale narrows the gap, make the comparison again.

A 256GB M4 needs a more substantial saving against a 512GB M5 because you’re accepting less storage. There isn’t one additional dollar amount that makes that compromise sensible for everyone. If you would immediately need a larger drive, don’t buy the smaller configuration just because its price looks good.

Condition changes the comparison again. A new laptop with a full warranty is worth more than one with an uncertain battery, missing charger or restrictive returns. Don’t apply the same $200 rule to a used M4 and a new M5 as if those were otherwise equivalent purchases.

Include any delivery charges and necessary accessories. A smaller invoice isn’t much of a saving if you spend the difference fixing a problem the cheaper computer arrived with.

What “Other sellers” means for the purchase

A product page without a prominent Add to Cart button is a reason to inspect the available offers. It isn’t evidence that every M4 has disappeared, and it doesn’t make every marketplace seller unsuitable. It does mean that the product name alone hasn’t told you who you’re buying from.

Open the offer and read the seller, condition, delivery estimate and return terms. “Ships from Amazon” and “Sold by Amazon” describe different things. Confirm who provides warranty service and whether the charger is included. If it’s a gift, check that the return window extends beyond the day it will be opened.

For used or refurbished machines, find out what is stated about battery condition and what happens if it doesn’t meet the description. A return policy you can use matters more than a vague assurance that a computer has been checked.

If the available offers are awkward to evaluate and the saving is small, choose the M5 from a seller with clear terms. You don’t need to turn an ordinary laptop purchase into a search for the last unit in a particular color.

Choose enough memory before choosing a generation

For routine work, 16GB is a sensible starting point. If your current laptop runs several demanding applications at once or struggles with large files, compare higher-memory configurations before making a choice. Buying the newest chip won’t make too little memory a good fit.

Both generations have memory options beyond the base capacity. [1][2] A higher-memory M4 could suit a particular workload better than a base M5. Check requirements for your editing software, engineering applications or local AI tools rather than relying on a general recommendation.

For someone who mostly uses a browser, email and documents, extra memory can also become an expensive precaution that stays unused. Budget for the work you expect to do, including the applications you need to keep open together.

The display and battery still matter

Both 13-inch models have a 13.6-inch display. Apple’s specifications list the same resolution and 500-nit brightness rating. Moving to the newer chip doesn’t automatically give you a larger workspace. [1][2]

Try the screen at a comfortable text size if you can. If you spend the evening leaning toward a 13-inch laptop, a larger Air or an external monitor may do more for you than a processor upgrade. Include that monitor in the budget.

Apple rates both for up to 18 hours of video streaming or 15 hours of wireless web use under its stated tests. Those are manufacturer test figures, not a prediction for a day of calls and photo editing. Used machines add battery wear to the comparison. A lower price is less appealing if the laptop already needs service. [1][2]

Check the desk setup and your software

Both models provide MagSafe charging, two Thunderbolt 4 ports and a headphone jack. Check Apple’s display-support specifications against your monitors and dock before ordering. Adapters may still be needed for USB-A equipment, memory cards or wired networking. [1][2]

Required software comes first. If a course or job depends on a program that doesn’t run properly on macOS, a discounted Mac doesn’t solve that requirement. Ask about the exact application and version before spending money on accessories or a workaround.

If you already own an M4

Keep it if it runs the applications you use and lasts long enough away from an outlet. More starting storage in a new model doesn’t help an owner whose current drive already has plenty of space.

If something is wrong, identify the problem first. A worn battery, a full drive or one troublesome application calls for a different response from a computer that can’t finish your work on time. Price the remedy before replacing the laptop. Buying an M5 makes sense when it addresses a limitation you actually have.

What we’d buy today

Start with the M5 Air, 16GB / 512GB, and check other capacities if your work needs them. Buy an M4 only when the exact configuration fits and a reputable seller offers a substantial saving. An old model with a small discount and an unclear offer has lost the reason to choose it.

Sources

Sources checked November 18, 2026. Price-gap thresholds are Znews editorial judgments, not advertised offers.

[1] Apple, MacBook Air 13-inch M4 technical specifications.

[2] Apple, current MacBook Air M5 technical specifications and current configurations.

[3] RTINGS, MacBook Air 13 M4 review, independent laptop testing.

As an Amazon Associate, Znews earns from qualifying purchases.